Written by David Roberts, MPH
A Johns Hopkins study measured how much sulforaphane the body recovers from different broccoli preparations. Glucoraphanin alone returned about 10%. Whole sprouts with the plant's own enzyme returned 35 to 41%. Stabilized sulforaphane skips the conversion step entirely.
Key Takeaways
- ✓Glucoraphanin alone converts at about 10%.
- ✓Adding the plant's own enzyme, myrosinase, roughly quadruples that.
- ✓Conversion ranges from 1% to 40% between people.
- ✓Stabilized sulforaphane needs no conversion step.
- ✓Labels list precursor content, not absorbed compound.
Two broccoli supplements can carry near-identical labels and deliver very different amounts of the compound you are buying them for.
The difference is not potency. It is whether the capsule contains the active compound or a precursor that your body still has to convert.
What are the three ways to get sulforaphane into your body?
There are three delivery approaches on the market, and they are not interchangeable.
Glucoraphanin alone. Broccoli sprout or seed powder containing the stable precursor, with no active enzyme. Conversion is left entirely to your gut.
Glucoraphanin with active myrosinase. Whole sprouts or seed powder where the plant's own enzyme is still intact, or where enzyme is added back.
Stabilized sulforaphane. The active compound itself, delivered directly, with no precursor and no conversion step.
All three can carry a number on the front of the bottle. Only the third is describing the compound you are trying to absorb.
That distinction is invisible on a shelf. It is not invisible in a laboratory, and researchers have measured exactly how much it costs.
What did the Johns Hopkins bioavailability study find?
That the enzyme matters more than the dose on the label.
A 2015 study from Jed Fahey's group at Johns Hopkins gave 22 volunteers different broccoli preparations, then measured sulforaphane metabolites in urine across a single 24-hour collection. [1]
The controls matter here. Volunteers ate no cruciferous vegetables for at least three days beforehand and fasted overnight, so the sulforaphane measured came from the preparation rather than dinner. [1]
Dr. Fahey directs the Brassica Chemoprotection Laboratory at Johns Hopkins, and his group has spent decades on cruciferous vegetables and the Nrf2 pathway. This is the benchmark dataset in the field.
Glucoraphanin without active enzyme returned 9.4% to 10.4% of the dose. Preparations where the plant's own myrosinase was intact returned 35% to 41%. The paper describes the difference as three to four-fold. [1]
The variability is important. Across an earlier cohort, individual conversion ranged from 1% to 40% of the dose given, with a mean of 11.5%. [1]
Two people can take the same glucoraphanin capsule and absorb fortyfold different amounts, because the conversion depends on their gut bacteria rather than the product.
| Preparation | Active myrosinase present | Recovered as sulforaphane |
|---|---|---|
| Glucoraphanin alone | No | 9.4% to 10.4% |
| Whole sprouts or seed powder | Yes, the plant's own | 35% to 41% |
| Stabilized sulforaphane | Not required | No conversion step, so gut bacteria and enzyme activity do not set the dose |
The first two rows are measured values from one study, one assay, one 24-hour window. The third row is not a measured recovery percentage and is not presented as one, because a product that skips conversion is not competing on conversion efficiency.
The sulforaphane pathway
Broccoli stores the precursor and the enzyme in separate compartments. Damage to the plant by chewing or blending brings them together.
The stable precursor in broccoli seeds and sprouts, also called sulforaphane glucosinolate (SGS). On its own, it does nothing.
The enzyme that converts glucoraphanin into sulforaphane.
The active isothiocyanate (ITC), and the molecule behind more than 2,000 peer-reviewed papers.
| BrocElite® Plus | Precursor-based supplements | |
|---|---|---|
| Active compound in the capsule | Sulforaphane, stabilized | Glucoraphanin, the inactive precursor, and sometimes myrosinase, the enzyme. |
| Needs conversion in your gut | No | Yes |
| Nrf2 induction measured in people | Yes, in cheek cells within two hours of a 10 mg serving [2] | Varies by product. Most publish precursor content only. |
| What the label figure represents | Sulforaphane, confirmed by batch testing | Precursor potential, before any conversion loss |
| Glyphosate residue testing | Certified glyphosate residue-free | Varies by product. |
| Fillers | None | Varies by product. Magnesium stearate and silicon dioxide are common. |
Does a higher glucoraphanin number mean more sulforaphane?
More glucoraphanin does not reliably equal more sulforaphane, and this is where label comparison shopping breaks down.
In the Johns Hopkins testing, recovery held steady at roughly 41% across doses of 50, 100, and 200 micromoles when active enzyme was present. The percentage was a property of the preparation, not the size of the dose. [1]
So a product listing twice the glucoraphanin of a competitor is promising twice the raw material, not twice the delivered compound. The conversion rate rides along unchanged.
If that rate is 10% because no active enzyme survived, doubling the precursor doubles a small number. The lever that matters is the form, not the quantity.
Does stomach acid destroy myrosinase?
Johns Hopkins data do not support this.
The researchers tested it directly, comparing standard gelatin capsules against acid-resistant capsules designed to survive the stomach and release further down. [1]
Standard capsules returned 35.1% of the dose. Acid-resistant capsules returned 32.7%. The difference was not statistically significant. [1]
What the authors concluded
Their own words: the results suggest that whether the capsule dissolved in the stomach or further along the digestive tract "made little difference in the extent of hydrolysis." [1]
The same paper also found that myrosinase in ground broccoli seed powder remained fully active after a year of storage in a freezer, a refrigerator, or at room temperature. The enzyme is sturdier than the marketing suggests. [1]
We are not going to argue a point that the best available study contradicts. The real problem with precursor-based products is not acid. It is that conversion depends on an organ you cannot standardize.
Why does glucoraphanin convert so inconsistently?
When the precursor, glucoraphanin, is ingested without the active enzyme, myrosinase, your gut bacteria have to do the work, and no two microbiomes are alike.
That is the mechanism behind the 1% to 40% range. Someone with the right bacterial populations converts reasonably well. Someone without them absorbs a fraction of what the label implies. [1]
Adding active myrosinase back into the product narrows that spread. The Johns Hopkins team reported that intact enzyme reduced variation both within and between subjects. [1]
It narrows the spread rather than removing it. Even at 41%, more than half the dose on the label is still not reaching you as sulforaphane.
Think about what that range means in practice. Buy a precursor product listing 30 mg of glucoraphanin, and the sulforaphane you receive could be anywhere from a fraction of a milligram to roughly twelve.
You have no way to tell which end you landed on. There is no symptom that reports conversion efficiency, and the bottle gives you the same number either way.
That is the problem a stabilized form is built to remove. Not to squeeze more out of the conversion, but to stop depending on it.
How is stabilized sulforaphane different?
It removes the conversion step from the equation by putting the finished compound in the capsule.
There is no precursor to hydrolyse, no enzyme that has to survive, and no dependence on which bacteria happen to be living in your intestine that week.
The hard part has never been the molecule. Sulforaphane is small and lipid-soluble, which is why it crosses membranes readily once it exists. [3]
The hard part is getting a stable, active form of it into a capsule that survives manufacturing, shipping and a year on a shelf. Sulforaphane degrades easily, especially in water.
Johns Hopkins researchers have published on one approach to this, complexing sulforaphane with alpha-cyclodextrin, and found the complexed form as bioavailable as pure sulforaphane while storing better. [4]
That study tested a different stabilization chemistry than ours. What it establishes is the principle: stabilization does not have to cost you bioavailability.
What makes the molecule worth this trouble is what it does on arrival. Sulforaphane modifies cysteine residues on a protein called Keap1, which releases the transcription factor Nrf2. [3]
Nrf2 then moves into the nucleus and switches on the genes for your own antioxidant and detoxification enzymes. Sulforaphane is the most potent naturally occurring activator of that pathway identified so far. [3]
Worth stating plainly: sulforaphane is not an antioxidant itself. It is the signal that tells your cells to make their own. [3]
What does "stabilized" mean on a supplement label?
Less than you would hope, because the word carries no regulatory definition. Any manufacturer can print it.
What it should mean is that the active compound survives manufacturing, shipping and months on a shelf in a form your body can still use when you open the bottle.
Different companies get there by different routes. The Johns Hopkins work used an alpha-cyclodextrin inclusion complex, essentially a molecular cage that protects the compound. [4]
Ours uses reverse osmosis water for extraction, with no chemical solvents at any stage. Those are different processes, and neither is implied by the word on the front of a bottle.
So the word is not the evidence. The evidence is whether a company can show you the compound is present, active, and confirmed in the batch you bought.
What has Mara Labs measured in its own testing?
Two things, and we label them as company data rather than independent research.
In live human cheek cells, one full serving of BrocElite® Plus, 10 mg across two capsules, induced Nrf2 within two hours of being swallowed. A comparable precursor-based product did not, in the same testing. [2]
In liver cells, BrocElite® Plus raised glutathione production 120% over baseline. Glutathione is one of the antioxidant systems Nrf2 switches on, so it serves as an indirect read on pathway activation. [2]
Worth being precise about what that second number is. It is a cell-culture measurement, not a demonstration that your circulating glutathione rises by 120%.
The buccal cell result is the one that matters most, because it was measured in people, after swallowing, on the normal serving size. [2]
What should you look for in a sulforaphane supplement?
Four questions separate products that have done the work from products that have done the marketing.
Does the capsule contain sulforaphane or glucoraphanin? If the label lists glucoraphanin, you are buying a precursor and the conversion is your problem.
Does the number on the label describe what was measured, or what is theoretically possible? A glucoraphanin figure is a ceiling, not a delivery.
Has the brand published testing on cellular activity, not just content? Nrf2 induction is the outcome. Raw material assays are an input.
Is every batch tested, or was one batch tested once? Those are different claims, and only one of them tells you about the bottle in your hand.
A brand that cannot answer these clearly is worth a second look before you buy. That applies to us as much as anyone else.
None of this makes precursor-based products worthless. Whole sprouts with the plant's own enzyme intact returned 35% to 41% in controlled testing, which is a real delivery. [1]
The argument is narrower than the category marketing usually makes it. It is about whether the amount reaching you is set by the manufacturer or by your digestion.
With a precursor, your gut decides. With the finished compound, the capsule decides. That is the whole difference, and it is the reason the delivery question comes before the dose question.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is glucoraphanin the same thing as sulforaphane?
No. Glucoraphanin is the stable precursor found naturally in broccoli seeds and sprouts, sometimes labelled as sulforaphane glucosinolate. It has no activity of its own. The enzyme myrosinase must cleave it to produce sulforaphane, the active isothiocyanate responsible for Nrf2 induction. A label listing glucoraphanin is describing what your body might make, not what it will receive.
How much glucoraphanin converts to sulforaphane?
In the Johns Hopkins study, glucoraphanin without active enzyme returned 9.4% to 10.4% of the dose as sulforaphane metabolites in urine over 24 hours. Preparations with the plant's own myrosinase intact returned 35% to 41%. Individual conversion in an earlier cohort ranged from 1% to 40%, with a mean of 11.5%, because the work falls to gut bacteria that differ from person to person.
Does stomach acid destroy myrosinase?
The evidence does not support it. Researchers compared standard gelatin capsules against acid-resistant capsules designed to bypass the stomach, and recovery was 35.1% versus 32.7%, a difference that was not statistically significant. The authors concluded that where the capsule dissolved made little difference to the extent of hydrolysis. The same study found myrosinase in ground seed powder still fully active after a year at room temperature.
Why did the study measure urine instead of blood?
Dithiocarbamate metabolites in urine are an established proxy for how much sulforaphane the body absorbed and processed. A single 24-hour collection captures the full window of excretion rather than one moment on a curve, which makes it a practical and reliable measure for comparing preparations against each other.
Was BrocElite® Plus tested in the Johns Hopkins study?
No. That study compared glucoraphanin preparations with and without active myrosinase, and it is cited here for what it establishes about conversion, not as a test of our product. BrocElite® Plus uses stabilized direct delivery, and its results come from Mara Labs' own testing, which is labelled as company data wherever it appears.
Does stabilizing sulforaphane require chemical solvents?
Not in our process. Mara Labs uses reverse osmosis water for extraction, and no chemical solvents at any stage of stabilization. Other manufacturers use other methods, and the published descriptions of competing processes vary, so this is a statement about how BrocElite® Plus is made rather than a claim about anyone else's manufacturing.
Sources
[1] Fahey, J.W., Holtzclaw, W.D., Wehage, S.L., Wade, K.L., Stephenson, K.K., Talalay, P. "Sulforaphane Bioavailability from Glucoraphanin-Rich Broccoli: Control by Active Endogenous Myrosinase." PLOS ONE, 2015;10(11):e0140963.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0140963
[2] Mara Labs, Gildea, J., Katz, M., Roberts, D. "Sulforaphane Induction of Nrf-2." White paper, Mara Labs Inc., 2023. Company data.
[3] Dinkova-Kostova, A.T., Fahey, J.W., Kostov, R.V., Kensler, T.W. "KEAP1 and done? Targeting the NRF2 pathway with sulforaphane." Trends in Food Science and Technology, 2017;69:257-269.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tifs.2017.02.002
[4] Fahey, J.W., Wade, K.L., Wehage, S.L., Holtzclaw, W.D., Liu, H., Talalay, P., Fuchs, E., Stephenson, K.K. "Stabilized sulforaphane for clinical use: Phytochemical delivery efficiency." Molecular Nutrition and Food Research, 2017;61(4):1600766.
https://doi.org/10.1002/mnfr.201600766
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Consult a healthcare professional before beginning any new supplement, especially if pregnant, nursing, on medication, or managing a condition. Individual results may vary.
0 Comments